Some episodes of Acton Line are interviews. This one was closer to a reunion.
Brad Birzer was my professor at Hillsdale College, and in the years since he has become a friend and a mentor whose judgment I still seek out on questions of history, faith, and what it means to write well. Those of you who attended the Acton Institute’s annual dinner this fall heard him speak, and if you did, you already know why I was eager to get him in front of a microphone. His new book, Tolkien and the Inklings: Men of the West, is the fruit of roughly twenty years of work, and our conversation ranged across all of it.
Brad’s 2002 study Sanctifying Myth left him wanting to go deeper into the friendship between J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis. Finishing the follow-up took far longer than he expected: other biographies intervened, so did a family tragedy, and two publishers went out of business along the way. What finally reignited the project was reading the posthumous Tolkien volumes edited by his son Christopher. There is something fitting about a book on friendship and perseverance having such a long and winding road to print.
One of my favorite stretches of the conversation concerns the state of science fiction and fantasy in the 1930s, when both genres were pulp, sold next to adult magazines and dismissed by serious readers. Tolkien and Lewis set out to change that. Around 1936 they reportedly flipped a coin: Tolkien would take time travel, Lewis would take space travel, and each would try to write something respectable in a disreputable form. The Inklings themselves grew out of Tolkien’s Old Norse reading group, the Coalbiters, and an Oxford undergraduate club, meeting from 1931 to 1949 at the Eagle and Child and, for the more selective Thursday readings, in Lewis’s rooms at Magdalen. They read far more than fiction to one another. Theology, philosophy, biography, and history were all on the table.
The heart of Brad’s argument is that the Inklings were deliberately anti-ideological. They regarded the great political and philosophical systems of their age as a kind of intellectual slavery, hostile to human dignity. Drawing on Aristotle and on Lewis’s The Four Loves, Brad describes their friendship as a secession from mass society, a small, chosen community that could stand against Nazism, Communism, and the broader pressures of radical modernity. Mediating institutions, voluntary associations, the little platoons: the Inklings were living one out at a pub table.
I was especially interested in the religious texture of the group, which was roughly 60 percent Protestant and 40 percent Catholic. There were real tensions. Hugo Dyson once threatened to leave if another Catholic were invited. Lewis carried the suspicions of his Ulster upbringing; Tolkien never forgot how his mother’s Protestant relatives cut her off after her conversion to Rome. But the bond held. What united them was a shared conviction that Christianity fulfills rather than destroys the pagan inheritance, an approach they modeled on St. Paul at the Areopagus in Acts 17. They wanted to baptize myth and, just as much, modern science.
Brad is candid about Charles Williams, whose occult past and idiosyncratic theological language unsettled some members, while also crediting Williams with ideas like romantic theology and co-inherence, the bearing of one another’s burdens, that shaped the group’s thinking.
We also took up the Inklings’ distinction, influenced by Owen Barfield, between mere rationality and reason in the fuller sense, the divine Logos reflected in the soul. For them, imagination was not an escape from truth but an instrument for perceiving it.
Brad doesn’t dodge the contemporary objections. On charges of colonialism and Eurocentrism, he argues that the Inklings’ “West” was the West of Socrates, Cicero, and Augustine, not of empire. Tolkien, he notes, disliked the phrase “Great Britain” and preferred a smaller, Shire-sized England. On the question of women, Brad concedes Lewis’s blind spots but defends Tolkien, pointing to Éowyn, Galadriel, and Lúthien, and to Tolkien’s record as a mentor to female students at Oxford.
I asked Brad for two starting points, one story and one history, and he gave these answers : The Lord of the Rings, which he expects to stand with Homer, Virgil, and Dante as the heroic romance of our age, and Plato’s Crito, for Socrates’ insistence that doing evil in pursuit of a good end corrupts the good itself. That principle, he suggested, is as close to the moral center of the Inklings as anything.
It was a privilege to have my old professor on the show again!

